How Many Crimes Can You See Being Committed In This Anti-Gun ‘Public Service’ Ad?

 

 

 

 

 

” I’ve gotten several e-mails about this ad, and one reader asked: If a child does what the protagonist did — would the filmmakers be criminally punishable or subject to civil liability? (If you don’t want to watch the ad, the short version is this: a teenager takes a gun from his mother’s drawer, brings it to school in a backpack, gives it to a horrified looking teacher, and says, “Can you take this away? I don’t feel safe with a gun in my house.”)

  The answer is likely no.

  This having been said, the ad strikes me as pretty appalling. I doubt that it’s persuasive advocacy for the proposition that people shouldn’t keep guns, shouldn’t keep guns when they have children in the house, or shouldn’t keep guns unlocked when they have children in the house. (Whether those are sound propositions is a separate question; I’m just saying the ad doesn’t really make much of an argument for them.) But I can imagine some impressionable teenager seeing what the appealing protagonist is doing, and trying to copy it, especially since the serious tone of the video seems to invite its being taken seriously. And the results could include expulsion, criminal prosecution, or even death.”

 

Read more

 

    The creators of this anti-gun “PSA” have hit new lows in encouraging children to commit no less than three felonies in their bid to rid the world of privately owned guns . The child who follows the example set in this specious video would be guilty of , in no particular order , theft of a firearm , illegal possession of a firearm and bringing a firearm into a “gun-free” school zone .

   Nothing like encouraging law-breaking to serve the public interest … The voting on Youtube for this video currently stands at over 13,000 negative views to just over 100 positive ones . The comments are well worth reading . 

   This takes the old communist method of getting children to snitch on their “disloyal” parents to new heights by encouraging your children to steal from you while they rat you out to the State .

 

   The Examiner adds further details including some contact information for the video’s creator:

 

 

” Several said they flagged the video as dangerous. One suggested reporting it to YouTube for being dangerous to children. Several said they already reported it. Sincic, apparently aware the video could be torn down by YouTube, also posted it to Vimeo, where it also attracted a number of critics.

  According to her website, Sincic is an Indian film director and screenwriter based in San Francisco. She also claims to have worked on a variety of projects including television, short films, commercials, corporate videos and feature films.”

 

 

 

   Read more on the outrage generated by this obscene “PSA” :

 

PSA encourages kids to steal parents’ guns, hand over to teachers

Anti-gun PSA encourages children to steal parents’ guns, give them to teachers

‘Gun Safety’ PSA Encourages Kids to Steal Parents’ Guns, Turn Them in at School

Anti-Gun PSA Encourages Kids To Steal Parents’ Guns